Use the issues you glean regarding the case analysis and reply to the post with a critique.
Write a 300 word critique of the analysis in Word (or equivalent). Apply the usual APA formatting for titles, headings, and any references you may use.

Ask questions and make observations about the case methodology, type of data and sources used, and manner in which he or she approached the analysis.
Include questions, observations, and suggestions about how what they did in the case study might apply to the analysis of their chosen company for the final project.

grade

Content (60%)   
a. Demonstrates understanding of the case    /10
b. Critiques the analysis of case study elements    /15
c. Discusses description of case study methods, suggesting alternatives where appropriate    /15
d. Judges whether the writer effectively applied criteria to the suitability of the case study methods    /20
Communication (25%)   
a. Uses language clearly and effectively    /10
b. Information organized intelligently and holistically (i.e., not simply answers to questions)    /10
c. Proper introduction and conclusion to paper    /5
Attention to Detail (15%)   
a. APA Formatting (title, headings, and references)    /10
b. Spelling and Grammar    /5
Total    /100